What happens if two people pick the same Dota 2 hero forever?

William Davis Published 19/04/2022

It sucks when your opponent picks the same hero that you wanted to play, but what if that happened for every single hero in Dota 2?

Dota 2 usually handles people picking the same hero in Ranked All Pick with grace. The hero gets banned, and both players move on to another pick. This is especially common when new builds take over the meta, but it happens with more niche picks all the same. A double pick ban is rare, but what happens if both players just keep picking the same hero over and over again? We have finally found the answer.

To test this, we set up a private lobby using the Ranked All Pick draft rules. Once the initial round of bans were over, the two players picked the same hero over and over again until something weird happened. We originally anticipated the test to take a long time, but it actually resolved quite quickly. 

The answer is that the pick bans continue for two heroes, then whoever locks in a hero first will have their pick honored. It’s somewhat anticlimactic, but it’s probably for the best. Otherwise, mischievous players could ban out the entire roster and soft lock all 10 players out of the game. Strangely, the chat will send different messages to the players based on who picked first. The second one will see that the hero has been banned while the picker will see nothing.

How many heroes can two people ban by picking them at the same time?

Dota 2 bans a few heroes at the start of each game, but is it possible to ban everyone by pick-banning every phase?

Based on the finding above, no. Assuming that 20 heroes are banned at the start of the pick phase, that leaves 123 remaining choices. Even if all 10 players conspire to pick the same hero, that can only ban 20 additional Dota 2 heroes. It’s possible that Dota 2 treats the two-hero pick ban limit as a “per phase” limit, so it could be as few as six additional bans.

That leaves two players picking the same hero at the exact same time, which simply isn’t going to happen in a real-life situation. Dota 2 is a little finicky about actions happening on the same tick, such as simultaneous debuffs or even both ancients dying. The player with less ping probably gets the hero. And if both pick a third simultaneous hero at the exact same time with the exact same ping? The servers explode. Probably. We weren’t able to test.

Read Also

Dota 2

Team Yandex stop the magic, defeating LGD in BLAST Slam VII finals Michael Hassall Team Yandex have defeated LGD Gaming in the grand finals of BLAST Slam VII in a dramatic 3-1 series that saw both teams pushed to the limit, but ultimately Yandex come out on top. Concluding the last major tournament before teams head to the Esports World Cup and The International 2026 next month and in August, Yandex were able to counter the momentum of LGD that had brought them into ...

Dota 2

BLAST Slam VII Finals Predictions and Picks – Can LGD make it all the way? Michael Hassall LGD Gaming in the top three of a tournament!? What is this 2021? BLAST Slam VII has been one of the most surprising tournaments of the year, and has capped off the pre-EWC and TI season with some of the most thrilling gameplay we’ve seen in months. And the finals are set to be even more exciting. With just three teams left there’s a lot on the line, from the ...

Dota 2

Easiest Dota 2 Heroes for Beginners – Best Picks to Learn the Game Simon Day We can all agree that Dota 2 is a complex game, but starting with the right heroes can make the learning process much smoother. Choosing one of the best Dota 2 heroes for beginners is key to building your skills and enjoying your matches. That’s why it’s time to explore the heroes that are easy to understand, effective in the game and great for learning the fundamentals. Without going into ...

Dota 2

BLAST Slam VII Playoffs Preview – Visa issues transform the playoff picture Michael Hassall BLAST Slam VII is the last major tournament before teams lock-in and compete at the EWC and The International, and as a result, we’re seeing a tournament with some unique outcomes. With teams seemingly treating this as a last-minute tune-up before the championship clashes of the next two months, a South American team has topped the table and some of the best teams in the world are either without players ...

Dota 2

TI-Champions Tundra Esports exit Dota 2 as roster transfers to 1win Michael Hassall Tundra Esports has revealed it’s leaving Dota 2 after six years and a victory at The International 2022. The UK-based organization has announced its roster will transfer directly to 1win for future events. The announcement, posted on Tundra's socials on June 1, confirms rumors and earlier social posts from 1win which hinted at a new lineup. With the move, however, questions about 1win’s existing EEU roster and attendance at The ...

Dota 2

A full weekend of TI15 tickets will cost you just $280 – If you don’t mind the view Michael Hassall Alongside the team invites for The International 2026, Valve today (May 26) unveiled the pricing and details of how to purchase tickets for TI15, and the price is the lowest in years. For years we’ve seen the price of The International Prize, with a peak of around $700 as a lowest price for a full weekend for both 2023 in Seattle, and 2024 in Copenhagen. But after a fall in ...

Dota 2

Valve has announced the TI15 invites: Here’s why some team names are very different Michael Hassall It’s around three months until The International 2026, TI15, and Valve has just unveiled the direct invites and qualifier invites to the event, but eagle-eyed fans will notice some strange names in the team lists. Valve unveiled the invites in the small hours of the morning on May 26 (late evening on May 25 for their HQ in Bellevue, Washington), detailing the seven direct invites, regional qualifier invites, and some ...