PhantomL0rd lawsuit reveals Twitch’s secret Strike Guide

Olivia Richman • April 29, 03:17

Twitch has been criticized quite harshly over the years for doling out inconsistent bans to its streamers, but a recent lawsuit revealed that the streaming platform may have a Strike Guide that it follows when it comes to these decisions. 

James “PhantomL0rd” Vargas won his lawsuit against Twitch on April 23. Twitch banned PhantomL0rd in 2016, and the trial’s jury eventually concluded the Amazon-owned company “breached its standard partner contract, acted in bad faith, and committed fraud” when it banned the streamer. 

“After nearly five years, I am grateful that a jury of my peers finally held Twitch accountable for its improper tactics against me, including my suspension,” PhantomL0rd wrote. 

While some were glad to see PhantomL0rd come out on top, it wasn’t the only interesting outcome of the lawsuit. In a TwitLonger, PhantomL0rd noted that Twitch had a Strike Guide. This is allegedly an “undisclosed list of rules violations.” The trial revealed the Strike Guide, he said, giving it the “scrutiny it deserved.” 

What is Twitch’s Strike Guide?

This was a major revelation to a lot of people in the streaming community. Not only is there allegedly a Strike Guide that helps Twitch determine what counts as a rule break and what punishment those rule breaks entail, the trial jury apparently didn’t much agree with it. 

“Twitch’s arbitrary and baseless punishment system was found to be improper. Regrettably, Twitch still does not comprehend how inappropriate its punishment system is and asked the court to place the secret ‘Strike Guide’ under seal,” PhantomL0rd said. 

PhantomL0rd stated that Twitch’s actions would soon be further revealed and the platform would be forced to treat all streamers fairly. He said that Twitch should evaluate its “illegal punishment system.” 

There will be a YouTube broadcast that will go into more details about the lawsuit and its information. Viewers will also be able to ask questions regarding the trial and its outcome.


Who owns every team in the Overwatch League?

Steven Rondina • February 24, 23:29

Twitch ran anti-union ads made by parent company Amazon

Steven Rondina • February 26, 01:09

Twitch responds to claims of sexual harassment against streamers

Olivia Richman • June 23, 05:43

DansGaming emote removal highlights Twitch’s inconsistent rules

Olivia Richman • November 11, 11:56

Everything to know about DMCA claims against Twitch streamers

Jessica Scharnagle • November 11, 20:20

The history of Ninja, from Halo to streaming on Twitch and Mixer

Olivia Richman • November 1, 12:00