win.gg
Win.gg News Madden 23 controversies include removed CPR, Mahomes rating

Madden 23 controversies include removed CPR, Mahomes rating

Author Icon
William Davis Published 03/02/2023

Madden 23 was meant to be a straightforward affair, but a series of controversies are impacting the franchise’s future.

Madden games are supposed to release like clockwork, with the most exciting new feature sometimes being the cover art. Its real draw is how closely it’s tied to the real-life NFL, with live stat adjustments and events based on the season. However, several problems, both real and digital, have plagued the title since its launch. Here are all the controversies facing Madden 23 explained.

Unfortunately, this year’s NFL season has brought some real-life tragedies that resulted in content being removed a little too late. In addition, technical problems have repeatedly prevented players from playing Madden 23 at all. And finally, on the gameplay side, Patrick Mahomes’ 98 rating has repeatedly soured many fans on the game’s accuracy to the real league. 

The game’s launch was immediately met with criticism for its technical issues. Even with several months of post-launch support, Madden 23 players are still reporting temporary lockouts and server outages. 

The worst problem of all is suddenly disappearing save files, which by this point can contain several months of progress. EA Sports has acknowledged these instances but has yet to announce a plan of action, leading many players to believe that the issue will never be solved.

Madden NFL 23 screenshot

In addition to technical issues, EA has also had to remove some in-game content to avoid referencing a real-life tragedy. Buffalo Bills safety Damar Hamlin went into cardiac arrest during a game after being tackled. The story quickly developed into a national tragedy, and Hamlin is still in the process of recovering. 

For Madden 23, however, it also meant an unintentionally tasteless interaction with a certain touchdown celebration animation where players performed CPR on each other. The animation was swiftly removed by EA Sports, but not before clips of it could be posted on the internet.

Madden 23 controversies spill into esports and licensing 

Despite a phenomenal season with 37 touchdowns and a shot at the Super Bowl, Patrick Mahomes still isn’t invited to Madden 23’s exclusive 99 club.

Life in the NFL can be hard, but getting maxed-out character stats in Madden appears to be even more difficult. This is something Kansas City Chiefs quarterback Patrick Mahomes can attest to. Despite an incredible season that could end with a Super Bowl championship, Mahomes’ in-game rating has yet to tick over 98. 

Mahomes started the season with a score of 95, which placed him behind two of the game’s enduring heroes in Tom Brady and Aaron Rodgers. His stats have slowly ticked up as the season has gone on, but in the final version of the game before Super Bowl LVII, he’s still just short of the maximum of 99.

This may seem like a small complaint, but the impacts bleed over into the Madden 23 esports world. Due to this rating, which a massive portion of the player base disagrees with, Madden 23 Mahomes will perform statistically worse in tournament settings.

By extension, this questionable decision will affect the betting scene surrounding the game. The odds algorithms used to develop match bets could be affected by this decision, which will result in real money being won or lost.  This doesn’t mention how the outcomes of Madden 23 esports matches may also be affected. In 2020, the NFL reached an agreement to extend their exclusive rights deal up to 2026 for a cost of $1.6 billion, which goes some way to showing the marketability of the game. However, controversies like these are disappointments for both fans and developers. As for its relationship with the actual NFL, the delayed removal of a CPR celebration certainly doesn’t help.  

William Davis
About William Davis

View full profile
Read Also
Duel Blackjack Reportedly Shut Down Amid Drama Between Sneako and Clavicular Kick
Duel Blackjack Reportedly Shut Down Amid Drama Between Sneako and Clavicular Khizar Mundia Nicolas “Sneako” Kenn De Balintha and Braden “Clavicular” Peters aren’t strangers to online drama, and the two creators have recently been beefing over Duel Casino. Surprisingly, during this very public conflict, Duel’s studio was reportedly entered by masked men, apparently leading to Duel Blackjack being inadvertently shut down. Drama and streamers go hand in hand, as both creators and the industry as a whole thrive on all types of limelight. ...
Brand Risk 16: Full Fight Card, Date, and Other Key Details Kick
Brand Risk 16: Full Fight Card, Date, and Other Key Details Khizar Mundia Adin Ross is back with another iteration of his boxing event, and Brand Risk 16 is pitting popular influencers against each other. Brand Risk is famous for featuring all types of fighters on its roster, including pro boxers, amateur fighters, or even normal streamers. The previous event, Brand Risk 15, for instance, featured bodybuilder and influencer Larry Wheels against Kick streamer Vitaly “Vitaly” Zdorovetskiy, with the match ending when the ...
Kai Cenat and BruceDropEmOff Beef Explained As the Two Finally Patch Things Up Twitch
Kai Cenat and BruceDropEmOff Beef Explained As the Two Finally Patch Things Up Khizar Mundia A multi-year streamer beef has ended, with Kai Cenat and Bruce “BruceDropEmOff” Ray Condones repairing their friendship after a rift began in 2023. BruceDropEmOff and Kai Cenat’s friendship was very public, as the two collaborated with each other and were otherwise known to be very close friends. This is why their public falling out took many fans by surprise. Bruce and Kai’s friendship deteriorated around the time when the former ...
Kai Cenat Finishes Wolverine Marathon, Backs iShowSpeed, and Teases IRL Series Twitch
Kai Cenat Finishes Wolverine Marathon, Backs iShowSpeed, and Teases IRL Series Khizar Mundia Twitch creator Kai Cenat's recent momentum is showing no signs of slowing down. He has just completed a Marvel’s Wolverine marathon, whilst also expressing support for his friend Darren “iShowSpeed” Watkins Jr. being crowned Streamer of the Year 2026. After a quiet start to the year, Cenat recently returned from his months-long break, and the streamer has been prolific in his output ever since. He first hosted Streamer University 2026, then ...
Kick’s Eddie Craven Addresses Ongoing KPP Complaints and Viewbotting Kick
Kick’s Eddie Craven Addresses Ongoing KPP Complaints and Viewbotting Khizar Mundia Several Kick streamers have taken to social media to publicly air their grievances about their KPP apparently being reduced. Kick director Ethan Wright recently responded to the complaints, and now Eddie Craven has also discussed the issue for creators. Stake-backed livestreaming platform Kick has made its place in the industry, in large part because of its higher revenue potential. While there have been one-off incidents where Kick has been criticized ...
Leaks Suggest That a Fortnite X One Piece Collaboration May Be Coming Fortnite
Leaks Suggest That a Fortnite X One Piece Collaboration May Be Coming Hannan Mundia Fortnite has collaborated with all sorts of franchises over the years, but a potentially leaked collaboration with One Piece may be the largest yet. When it comes to games collaborating with known IPs, it’s borderline impossible to compete with Fortnite. The battle royale game has some insane collaborations under its belt, including one with Kingdom Hearts when the Square Enix IP’s popularity is at an all-time high. However, if recent ...
FaZe Banks Thinks N3on’s AI Clone Could Be Worth $100M — How AI Is Changing Streaming Kick
FaZe Banks Thinks N3on’s AI Clone Could Be Worth $100M — How AI Is Changing Streaming Khizar Mundia Rangesh “N3on” Mutama may have received widespread backlash following his decision to use an AI model for certain content, but FaZe boss Richard “Banks” Bengtson has compared the streamer to legendary TikToker Khaby Lame. N3on was recently in the limelight after viewers noticed that a GTA 6 streamer NPC resembles him. The Kick streamer wasted no time in recreating the GTA 6 Netflix Extended Look in an IRL livestream, and ...