GTA 6 vs Ocarina of Time Remake: Which Game Will Win GOTY?

Grand Theft Auto 6 has been almost universally praised since its launch on November 19, and the game also secured multiple nominations at The Game Awards before being commercially released. It appears GTA 6’s main opponent for that honor will be The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time, Nintendo’s game which also released to much hype on November 5.
The latest Rockstar Games installment has received multiple perfect-score reviews, while several notable streamers began livestreaming the game as soon as its staggered release got underway. Ocarina of Time has also attracted widespread critical acclaim, with reviewers similarly praising the Nintendo title. With both games nominated for GOTY, GTA 6 and Ocarina of Time Remake look set to be the two main contenders, according to Game of the Year prediction markets.
GTA 6 launched with a 99 Metacritic score compared to Ocarina of Time Remake’s 96
Image credit: GTA 6, Ocarina of Time Remake
One of the highest scores in the history of Metacritic has famously been attached to Ocarina of Time. The original Nintendo 64 version has a score of 99 and also a massive fan following. Fans had been asking for the game to be remade for years, which is why the announcement was met with a massively positive response from the community. Ocarina of Time Remake also has a strong Metacritic score, but it’s lower than the original at 96.
GTA 6 received a Metacritic score as soon as the game launched in New Zealand, and surprisingly, it was 99. This puts the game on par with Ocarina of Time rather than the 2026 remake, at least critically. Ocarina of Time Remake’s score is still clearly impressive, because Nintendo mostly kept things similar to the almost three-decade-old classic.
GTA 6 and Ocarina of Time Remake are poles apart
GTA 6 has been praised for the realistic graphics and mechanics that are in the game, and there has also been much hype about the open world. Players can interact with countless NPCs, and there are countless activities that can be pursued rather than focusing on the main story. The fear that GTA 6 may have technical difficulties is also seemingly being debunked, as the game has been praised for its excellent performance. There are reports of some players experiencing FPS drops, but it remains to be seen how Rockstar changes things with updates.
Ocarina of Time Remake is a more straightforward and linear game compared to GTA 6. It has maintained the dungeons, narrative, and NPCs of the original Zelda classic. The game has received praise for modernizing an iconic title while retaining what made the original Ocarina of Time popular. Numerous new players have played the game alongside returning veterans, and its art direction and simplicity have been major talking points ahead of awards season.
GTA 6 has received eight nominations compared to Ocarina of Time Remake’s four
Both titles have fared well at The Game Awards, but GTA 6 has received the most award nominations out of all the games. GTA 6 isn’t just a contender for GOTY, but is also competing for Best Narrative, Art Direction, Game Direction, Score and Music, Performance, Audio Design, and Action/Adventure Game. This isn’t a small feat, especially with the game not having been commercially launched at the time of the nominations.
Image credit: The Game Awards
Ocarina of Time Remake is facing off against GTA 6 in all four categories the Nintendo title is nominated in. These categories include GOTY, Best Art Direction, Best Score and Music, and Best Action/Adventure Game. Both games have other competitors they have to face off against, but the two are looking like the main contenders in the race for GOTY.
Ocarina of Time has received substantial critical acclaim, with fans also calling on Nintendo to remake more of its classic titles, including Majora’s Mask. The positive reception suggests the remake has successfully lived up to the expectations surrounding one of gaming’s most legendary titles. This is particularly notable given the challenges that come with reimagining such a well-regarded classic, with the finished product having had plenty of potential to disappoint fans.
In contrast, GTA 6 has only just begun rolling out across different time zones, meaning many fans are still waiting for their opportunity to play the game. Despite this, its numerous nominations at The Game Awards suggest that the jury has already been hugely impressed by Rockstar’s latest release.
The battle for GOTY is far from settled, but GTA 6 appears to have the edge heading into the ceremony on December 10, despite Ocarina of Time Remake putting together an impressive campaign of its own.
Feature image credit: GTA 6, Ocarina of Time Remake
Khizar Mundia has been playing video games for as long as he can recall. Things have come a long way since the many days he spent playing the original NES, though. He now covers a variety of competitive games and esports, as well as the world of streaming, ranging from Twitch to Kick. If it’s of interest to gamers, it’s of interest to Khizar.
View full profileRead Also
GTA
GTA
GTA
GTA
GTA
GTA
GTA