Rotating PogChamp emote on Twitch causes lots of controversy

Olivia Richman Published 13/01/2021

Twitch was planning to replace the PogChamp emote with a new face from the streaming community every day for the rest of 2021. But that experiment might not make it that far. Like almost everything on Twitch, the rotating PogChamp emote has become a source of drama, often targeted at the individuals featured as the emote that day. 

The PogChamp emote was recently removed because it was based on Ryan “Gootecks” Gutierrez’s face. The gamer had recently used Twitter to seemingly support riotous violence at Capitol Hill. The community responded with general support for Twitch’s decision, with many viewers promoting their favorite streamers as the potential new face of the PogChamp emote. 

This led Twitch to announce that they wanted the “sentiment and use of Pog to live on” in a January 6 tweet. The solution? Use a different streamer’s face for the PogChamp emote every 24 hours. This was positively received at first, but some recent content creators have started to get harassment after they were announced as the emote of the day. 

CriticalBard faces racism, harassment after being chosen as PogChamp emote

Actor and vocalist Omega Jones, known as CriticalBard on Twitch, was the PogChamp on January 11. CriticalBard stated that he received “a lot of hurtful messages and death threats” in response to the announcement. 

“I did prep my Twitch and Discord moderators about what was probably going to happen, considering I’m a black man who is about to be the face of a global emote Twitch has loved for so long,” CriticalBard told Polygon. 

The harassment CriticalBard received appeared to be based on a comment the streamer made during a recent live broadcast. He had been discussing the difference between Black Lives Matter and saying “white lives matter.” People started taking one of his quotes, that “white lives don’t matter,” out of its original context. The statement was originally from CriticalBard explaining how being proud to be white is not the same as being proud to be black. 

“Black folk have to say Black Lives Matter because we were stolen from a country, […] stripped of our heritage and our identities. All we know is our blackness. There’s a difference,” CriticalBard said to his viewers. 

Not everyone was convinced by the response. Some took to Twitter to accuse Twitch of “reverse racism.” They explained that CriticalBard was allowed to be “racist to white people” while Twitch had banned Gootecks’ emote after he was accused of being racist. 

Harassment and drama defines Twitch’s PogChamp plan

While the harassment over becoming the new PogChamp was expected, it seemed that CriticalBard’s biggest issue was Twitch’s lack of action in response to the situation. CriticalBard felt that Twitch could have done more to stop a lot of the harassment by banning people who “fueled the flames.” 

The streaming community supported CriticalBard at large, agreeing with the sentiment that Twitch should have been more proactive in anticipating the response. While the concept of a constantly changing PogChamp is fun in theory, many people on Twitch believe that the streaming platform should have thought more about how it would bring attention to chosen content creators. 

The next day, Twitch announced drag queen Deere as its new PogChamp inspiration.  

Homophobia and transphobia flooded the replies on Twitter, with many people demanding the return of Gootecks instead. Others called the new emote “trash,” while still others said that the PogChamp emotes were getting “worse and worse” by the day.

Twitter users quickly pointed out that Twitch wasn’t doing enough to stop the ensuing harassment and wasn’t allowing the PogChamp streamers to properly protect themselves from the incoming bullying. While some people replied that the streamers should get “thicker skin,” others have called on Twitch to address the harassment caused by the platform’s attempt at being inclusive.

What most everyone can agree on is that Twitch’s decision to rotate the face of PogChamp has created more drama for everyone involved.

Olivia Richman

About Olivia Richman

Olivia has worked in media ever since graduating from college, with her coverage ranging from traditional newspaper reporting to digital coverage of all things gaming, online betting, and nerd culture. She has traveled around the world pursuing that coverage, from the far coasts of the United States to the busy downtown core of Tokyo, Japan. Olivia’s favorite games include Overwatch and Super Smash Smash Bros, and she has been published at Esports Illustrated, Inven Global, EsportsInsider, Upcomer, and elsewhere.

View full profile

Read Also

Kick

Kick’s Eddie Craven Addresses Ongoing KPP Complaints and Viewbotting Khizar Mundia Several Kick streamers have taken to social media to publicly air their grievances about their KPP apparently being reduced. Kick director Ethan Wright recently responded to the complaints, and now Eddie Craven has also discussed the issue for creators. Stake-backed livestreaming platform Kick has made its place in the industry, in large part because of its higher revenue potential. While there have been one-off incidents where Kick has been criticized ...

Fortnite

Leaks Suggest That a Fortnite X One Piece Collaboration May Be Coming Hannan Mundia Fortnite has collaborated with all sorts of franchises over the years, but a potentially leaked collaboration with One Piece may be the largest yet. When it comes to games collaborating with known IPs, it’s borderline impossible to compete with Fortnite. The battle royale game has some insane collaborations under its belt, including one with Kingdom Hearts when the Square Enix IP’s popularity is at an all-time high. However, if recent ...

Kick

FaZe Banks Thinks N3on’s AI Clone Could Be Worth $100M — How AI Is Changing Streaming Khizar Mundia Rangesh “N3on” Mutama may have received widespread backlash following his decision to use an AI model for certain content, but FaZe boss Richard “Banks” Bengtson has compared the streamer to legendary TikToker Khaby Lame. N3on was recently in the limelight after viewers noticed that a GTA 6 streamer NPC resembles him. The Kick streamer wasted no time in recreating the GTA 6 Netflix Extended Look in an IRL livestream, and ...

Twitch

Twitch Is Testing An AI Stream Coach — Here’s How It Works Khizar Mundia Amazon-backed livestreaming platform Twitch is testing a new feature that will act as an AI coach for streamers, giving them personalized feedback to improve. Twitch has been playing around with several experimental features to improve things for its users. One of these includes auto clips, which was a feature that would automatically generate clips from the best moments of a stream. Another is AI-generated summaries of what happened in a ...

Twitch

Kai Cenat Talks Streamer University, Vivet, and Streaming Future Khizar Mundia Kai Cenat recently sat down with The New York Times for an interview. In a wide-ranging discussion, the Twitch streamer talked about what he looks for in Streamer University participants, and also delved into both his Vivet brand, as well as what the future holds. Kai Cenat may have gone on a break following his massively successful Mafiathon 3, but the creator returned with with a bang in Streamer University ...

League of Legends

Riot Games eyes Polymarket and Kalshi for esports sponsorships Michael Hassall Riot Games, the creator of League of Legends and VALORANT is reportedly exploring the protentional of sponsorship deals with prediction market operators including Polymarket and Kalshi, as per reports emerging late last night (Sep. 10). First reported by Cecilia D’Anastasio of Bloomberg, Riot has started conversations with the two top prediction market operators, Kalshi and Polymarket, with a view to one or both of them becoming sponsors within Riot Games’ ...

Slots

This Is How Gates of Olympus 2500 Builds On The Iconic Series Ian John Since the first Gates of Olympus slot hit casinos in 2021, the series has evolved into one of the most recognisable in the Pragmatic Play stable. The combination of scatter wins, tumbling symbols and dramatic multipliers has established a formula that has been followed in a number of sequels and spin-offs. The latest in that series is the Gates of Olympus 2500 slot, but this game takes a slightly more ...